Abstract
-
Objective
To investigate compliance with a viscosity-modified diet among Korean dysphagic patients and to determine which factors are associated with compliance.
-
Methods
We retrospectively reviewed medical records of patients who had been recommended to use thickeners in the previous videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS). Among 68 patients, 6 were excluded because tube feeding was required due to deterioration in their medical condition. Finally, 62 patients were included in the study. Patient compliance was assessed using their medical records by checking whether he or she had maintained thickener use until the next VFSS. To determine which factors affect compliance, the relationship between thickener use and patient characteristics, such as sex, age, inpatient/outpatient status, severity of dysphagia, aspiration symptoms, follow-up interval of VFSS, and current swallowing therapy status were assessed. For noncompliers, reasons for not using thickeners were investigated by telephone interview.
-
Results
Among 62 patients, 35 (56.5%) were compliers, and 27 (43.5%) were noncompliers. Eighteen (90%) of 20 inpatients had followed previous recommendations; however, only 17 (40.5%) of 42 outpatients had been using thickeners. Of patient characteristics, only admission status was significantly correlated with compliance. When asked about the reason why they had not used thickeners, noncompliers complained about dissatisfaction with texture and taste, greater difficulty in swallowing, and inconvenience of preparing meals.
-
Conclusion
Among Korean dysphagic patients, compliance with a viscosity-modified liquid diet was only about 50%. Betterments of texture and taste along with patient education might be necessary to improve compliance with thickener use.
-
Keywords: Compliance, Deglutition disorders, Diet therapy
INTRODUCTION
The term "dysphagia" is applied to all kinds of swallowing difficulties. The condition is clinically common and can be attributed to various diseases including disorders of the central nervous system, such as stroke and traumatic brain injury, neurodegenerative diseases, such as Parkinson disease and Alzheimer disease, disorders of the peripheral nervous system, neuromuscular junction disorders, myopathies, and local anatomical lesions [
1]. Major complications of dysphagia are pneumonia, malnutrition, dehydration, and increased mortality. These complications bring about the increased need of medical resources in terms of the length of hospital stay, rehabilitation time, the need for long-term care assistance, and health care cost [
2].
Altering the characteristics of food is one of the common approaches used to treat and compensate dysphagia [
3]. Size, color, shape, taste, viscosity, and texture are components of the characteristics of food. In general, thin fluid, such as water, soup, or juice is more likely to be aspirated [
4]; therefore, thickening fluid using thickeners is the mainstay of dysphagia diet [
5]. One study of 66 dysphagic patients documented that thickened fluid and soft mechanical diet reduced the incidence of pneumonia by 80% compared with a regular diet [
6].
Despite these advantages, many patients and caregivers are reluctant to make modifications to the diet. It has been demonstrated that 75% of the patients who were recommended to modify diet with thickeners did not prefer using them [
7]. According to a study in the United States, there was a disjunction between the expectations of medical staffs and what patients are really doing. Speech-language pathologists expected a higher compliance of 72%; however, only 36% patients followed their instructions on thickener use [
8].
No study has documented, however, the level of compliance with a viscosity-modified diet in Korea. The purposes of the present study were to examine compliance with a viscosity-modified diet among Korean dysphagic patients and to evaluate relevant factors affecting compliance.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Subjects
A retrospective chart review was performed in Seoul National University Hospital, a university-affiliated tertiary care hospital. From June 1 to September 30, 2011, a total of 349 patients underwent a videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS). We included only those who had been recommended thickener use in fluids in the previous VFSS within 6 months (
Fig. 1). Among 349 patients, modified diet including thickened liquids was prescribed in 68 patients. Among those, 6 required nasogastric tube feeding due to the development or deterioration of their medical condition. Finally, 62 dysphagic subjects were included in the analysis.
Demographic and clinical data of study subjects are shown in
Table 1. The mean age at VFSS was 64.1 years. The mean interval time between the studies was 55.7 days on average, and half of the patients had dysphagia secondary to brain lesion, such as stroke or brain tumor.
Through medical chart review, data on age, sex, diagnosis, admission status (outpatient or inpatient), current diet, recommended diet regimen in the previous VFSS, videofluoroscopic dysphagia scale (VDS) [
9], symptoms of aspiration, and current status in swallowing therapy were identified. At our institution, just before the VFSS, all patients or caregivers are routinely asked about the current diet and whether they have maintained the use of thickeners or not. Compliance was defined as using thickeners in liquids, such as water and juice. Accordingly, patients were categorized into two groups: compliant and noncompliant. Furthermore, we analyzed factors affecting compliance among the clinical characteristics of study subjects including sex, age, admission status, prescribed viscosity level, interval between swallowing studies, presence of aspiration symptoms, severity of dysphagia in VDS, and current status of swallowing therapy.
For patients in the noncompliant group, the reasons for cessation of thickener use and, if any, his or her own compensatory maneuvers were assessed by phone interview. For each question, multiple answers were allowed.
Statistical analysis
All statistical analyses were performed with the PASW Statistics ver. 18 for Windows software (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). To decide which factors are associated with compliance among patient characteristics, chi-square tests and univariate logistic regression analyses were used for categorical variables and continuous variables, respectively. In multiple logistic regression analysis, variables showing p<0.2 in the univariate analysis were included. For multiple analysis, the stepwise forward procedure was used for variable entry.
RESULTS
Among 62 patients, 35 (56.5%) had been using thickeners in liquids; however, 27 (43.5%) had been drinking thin fluids. Consequently, the overall compliance rate for viscosity modification was 56.5%. Twenty subjects were inpatients at the time of follow-up VFSS, and 18 (90%) of 20 were compliant. On the contrary, among a total of 42 outpatients, 17 (40.5%) were following the recommendations. Thus, the admission status (inpatient or outpatient) proved to be significantly associated with compliance (p=0.001) (
Fig. 2). However, compliance was not shown to be significantly correlated with following factors: sex, age, prescribed viscosity level, interval between swallowing studies, presence of aspiration symptoms, and severity of dysphagia in VDS. A trend toward higher compliance in those currently receiving swallowing therapy was observed; however, the difference was insignificant (p=0.108; odds ratio, 2.86). Finally, admission status and current swallowing therapy status were included in the multiple logistic regression model. In the analysis, compliance was shown to be significantly associated with admission status (p=0.004); however, no correlation was found between compliance and current application of swallowing therapy (p=0.532).
Among the noncompliant, ten patients responded to the interview regarding the reasons for not using thickeners, whereas the others were not available as a result of phone connection failure, no answer, death, etc. Responses included dissatisfaction with texture (4 patients), dissatisfaction with taste (4 patients), difficulty in preparation (2 patients), and greater difficulty in swallowing (2 patients) (
Table 2). Concerning compensatory maneuvers, 2 patients answered that they swallow fluids by splitting in small amounts using a straw or a spoon. One patient said, "I eat in the chin-tuck position." Another patient said, "I use glutinous rice flour to thicken fluids rather than commercialized thickeners."
DISCUSSION
This is the first study demonstrating compliance with a viscosity-modified diet in Korean dysphagic patients. The overall compliance for fluid-thickening was 56.5%, and this finding is in close agreement with those of previous studies from other countries documenting compliance with a dysphagia diet [
8,
10,
11]. According to one study in New Zealand [
10], 18 (21%) out of 86 patients with dysphagia were never compliant with fluid-thickeners, whereas the other 68 patients (79%) sometimes or always followed the prescribed dietary regimen. Even though compliance in their study is higher than that of the present study, the difference may arise from the distinct definition of compliance in each study. Another study in the United Kingdom found that 48% of the patients complied with the recommendations of speech and language therapists [
11]. In another study in the United States, only 36% maintained thickener use [
8]. Compliance in these studies was lower compared to that in the present study. However, these studies were conducted among outpatients. Among outpatients of the present study, we observed markedly similar compliance.
Admission status was the only factor which was proven to be associated with compliance. Other variables including age, sex, aspiration symptoms, and even current swallowing therapy status did not significantly affect compliance. According to the previous studies, however, younger and institutionalized patients were more likely to be noncompliant. In the study, the authors commented that such an unexpected age difference appears to be caused by a survival effect which reflects higher mortality among noncompliant older people. Furthermore, persons who live in community facilities usually do not prepare their meals by themselves, thus leading to higher levels of compliance due to passivity [
10]. The results of the present study which demonstrated inpatients' higher compliance correspond with this finding. We expected that patients who maintained swallowing therapy until the follow-up VFSS would be more compliant, and the results were in close agreement with this prediction; however, the difference did not reach statistical significance. This warrants a further study with a larger sample size.
Regarding the reasons for not using thickeners, many patients complained of dissatisfaction with texture and taste (4 patients each). Some patients reported that preparing a dysphagia diet is inconvenient, or reported aggravation of swallowing difficulty with thickener use. According to a previous study concerning noncompliance with swallowing recommendations, dissatisfaction with diet modifications was reported by all participants, followed by open denial, calculated risk, and minimization, in order of frequency [
12].
The most commonly used methods to deal with patient noncompliance with diet modifications are education and involvement of others [
12]. One intervention study demonstrated a significant improvement in compliance with thickener use (48% to 64%) after having the participants undergo a program based on an in-house training scheme and pre-thickened drinks [
11]. In the present study, clinical dietitians provided a structured educational program for all the inpatients and some outpatients (
Table 3,
Fig. 3). Therefore this may be the reason for the difference in compliance between outpatients and inpatients. The result opens the possibility of further investigations concerning the effects of educational programs on compliance.
This study has important limitations that mostly stem from its small sample size and retrospective design. First, the evaluation of compliance depended on the patients' recollection. Even though we should acknowledge the efficiency of this design since we cannot practically monitor all the patients, there exist possibilities of recall bias, lie and false response. Second, compliance was assessed dichotomously only. In further research, it can be subdivided into many grades. Additionally, utilization of a prospective design in future studies may increase the response rate for the reasons of noncompliance and compensatory maneuvers.
In conclusion, among Korean dysphagic patients, compliance with a viscosity-modified liquid diet was found to be only about 50%. Betterments of texture and taste along with patient education might be necessary to improve compliance with thickener use.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
REFERENCES
- 1. Olszewski J. Causes, diagnosis and treatment of neurogenic dysphagia as an interdisciplinary clinical problem. Otolaryngol Pol 2006;60:491-500.
- 2. Sura L, Madhavan A, Carnaby G, Crary MA. Dysphagia in the elderly: management and nutritional considerations. Clin Interv Aging 2012;7:287-298.
- 3. Groher ME, McKaig TN. Dysphagia and dietary levels in skilled nursing facilities. J Am Geriatr Soc 1995;43:528-532.
- 4. Feinberg MJ, Knebl J, Tully J, Segall L. Aspiration and the elderly. Dysphagia 1990;5:61-71.
- 5. Curran J, Groher ME. Development and dissemination of an aspiration risk reduction diet. Dysphagia 1990;5:6-12.
- 6. Groher ME. Bolus management and aspiration pneumonia in patients with pseudobulbar dysphagia. Dysphagia 1987;1:215-216.
- 7. Macqueen C, Taubert S, Cotter D, Stevens S, Frost G. Which commercial thickening agent do patients prefer? Dysphagia 2003;18:46-52.
- 8. Leiter AE, Windsor J. Compliance of geriatric dysphagic patients with safe-swallowing instructions. J Med Speech Lang Pathol 1996;4:289-300.
- 9. Kim DH, Choi KH, Kim HM, Koo JH, Kim BR, Kim TW, et al. Inter-rater reliability of videofluoroscopic dysphagia scale. Ann Rehabil Med 2012;36:791-796.
- 10. Low J, Wyles C, Wilkinson T, Sainsbury R. The effect of compliance on clinical outcomes for patients with dysphagia on videofluoroscopy. Dysphagia 2001;16:123-127.
- 11. Rosenvinge SK, Starke ID. Improving care for patients with dysphagia. Age Ageing 2005;34:587-593.
- 12. King JM, Ligman K. Patient noncompliance with swallowing recommendations: reports from speech-language pathologists. Contemp Issues Commun Sci Disord 2011;38:53-60.
Fig. 1Flow chart of the study design.
Fig. 2Compliance difference between outpatients and inpatients. Outpatients showed lower compliance than inpatients (n=62).
Fig. 3Examples of modified diet. (A) Liquids with honey-like viscosity and mechanically altered solids. (B) Liquids with nectar-like viscosity and pureed solids.
Table 1Demographic and clinical data of study participants (n=62)
Table 2Reason for noncompliance (total 10 patients)
Table 3Structured educational program for dysphagic patients and caregivers
Figure & Data
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
- The Effects of Adding Particles in Texture Modified Food on Tongue Strength and Swallowing Function in Patients with Oropharyngeal Dysphagia: A Proof of Concept Study
Leen Van den Steen, Edwig Goossens, Martijn van Gemst, Geertrui Vlaemynck, Bart Geurden, Gwen Van Nuffelen
Dysphagia.2025; 40(2): 501. CrossRef - Sensory Implications of Thickened Beverages for Dysphagia: Taste-Texture Interactions
Gunalan Dhamodharan, Allison Cox, James Makame, Alissa A. Nolden
LWT.2025; : 117880. CrossRef - Acceptability of a Protein Oral Nutritional Supplement with Xanthan Gum in Patients with Neuromuscular Diseases and Dysphagia: A Cross-Sectional Study
Federica Felloni, Luca Costantini, Michela Coccia
Gastrointestinal Disorders.2025; 7(2): 34. CrossRef - Dysphagia Education and Diet Modification: Preparing Clinicians to Make Patient-Focused Decisions Through Experiential Learning
Martha H. Sherrill, Charles Lenell
Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups.2024; 9(1): 249. CrossRef - Adherence to commercial food thickener in patients with oropharyngeal dysphagia
Amaya Peñalva-Arigita, Maria Lecha, Anna Sansano, Rosa Prats, Aida Vásquez, Helena Bascuñana, Lluis Vila
BMC Geriatrics.2024;[Epub] CrossRef - Effect of carbonation and thickening on voluntary swallow in healthy humans
Hajime Iwamori, Jin Magara, Wakana Onuki, Reiko Ita, Anna Sasa, Takanori Tsujimura, Makoto Inoue
Journal of Oral Rehabilitation.2024; 51(10): 2043. CrossRef - Difference in Performance of Health Professionals on the Use of Food Thickeners for Dysphagia
Jae hyun Seol, Hyun jung Hwang, Dae young Kim, Kyung hee Lee, Kyung ai Yang, Young cheon Song, Joonhee Lee, Kyoung Hyo Choi, Eun jung Park, Young-jin Song
Journal of the Korean Dysphagia Society.2024; 14(2): 101. CrossRef - Rheological Issues on Oropharyngeal Dysphagia
Crispulo Gallegos, Mihaela Turcanu, Getachew Assegehegn, Edmundo Brito-de la Fuente
Dysphagia.2023; 38(2): 558. CrossRef - A Review of Factors Contributing to Adults' Adherence to Dysphagia Dietary Recommendations Through an Ecological Lens
Bedoor S. Nagshabandi, Lauren Zinnershine, Samantha E. Shune
American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology.2023; 32(1): 341. CrossRef - Informed or misinformed consent and use of modified texture diets in dysphagia
Shaun T. O’Keeffe, Paula Leslie, Tracy Lazenby-Paterson, Arlene McCurtin, Lindsey Collins, Aoife Murray, Alison Smith, Siofra Mulkerrin
BMC Medical Ethics.2023;[Epub] CrossRef - Factors Associated With Resident Intake of Thickened Liquids in Long-Term Care
Sophia Werden Abrams, Heather Keller, Natalie Carrier, Christina Lengyel, Susan E. Slaughter, Ashwini Namasivayam-MacDonald
Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups.2023; 8(3): 558. CrossRef - The Adverse Effects and Events of Thickened Liquid Use in Adults: A Systematic Review
Sophia Werden Abrams, Pooja Gandhi, Ashwini Namasivayam-MacDonald
American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology.2023; 32(5): 2331. CrossRef - Transient receptor potential channels as an emerging therapeutic target for oropharyngeal dysphagia
Mohammad Zakir Hossain, Junichi Kitagawa
Japanese Dental Science Review.2023; 59: 421. CrossRef - Free from Dysphagia? A Test Battery to Differentiate Between Mild and No Dysphagia
Emma Lindroos, Kerstin Johansson
Dysphagia.2022; 37(3): 501. CrossRef - Thickened Liquids Using Pureed Foods for Children with Dysphagia: IDDSI and Rheology Measurements
Laura Brooks, Jianshan Liao, Jaclyn Ford, Sarah Harmon, Victor Breedveld
Dysphagia.2022; 37(3): 578. CrossRef - Risk of an Adverse Event in Individuals Who Aspirate: A Review of Current Literature on Host Defenses and Individual Differences
Phyllis M. Palmer, Aaron H. Padilla
American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology.2022; 31(1): 148. CrossRef - Short-Term Therapeutic Adherence of Hospitalized Older Patients with Oropharyngeal Dysphagia after an Education Intervention: Analysis of Compliance Rates, Risk Factors and Associated Complications
Jesús Mateos-Nozal, Elisabeth Sánchez García, Beatriz Montero-Errasquín, Estela Romero Rodríguez, Alfonso J. Cruz-Jentoft
Nutrients.2022; 14(3): 413. CrossRef - A Comparative Study on the Effect of Acute Pharyngeal Stimulation with TRP Agonists on the Biomechanics and Neurophysiology of Swallow Response in Patients with Oropharyngeal Dysphagia
Noemí Tomsen, Omar Ortega, Daniel Alvarez-Berdugo, Laia Rofes, Pere Clavé
International Journal of Molecular Sciences.2022; 23(18): 10773. CrossRef - Compliance and effect of thickener use in dysphagia patients with brain lesions: An observational pilot study
Hye Joon Ahn, Min Ho Chun, Junekyung Lee
Medicine.2022; 101(38): e30600. CrossRef - Adapting the International Dysphagia Diet Standardisation Initiative in East Asia: Feasibility study
Woo Chul Son, Ji Yeon Min, Hee Tae Shin, Kyung Cheon Seo, Kyoung Hyo Choi
Medicine.2022; 101(42): e31137. CrossRef - Postextubation dysphagia, or icu-acquired swallowing dysfunction
I.N. Pasechnik, A.E. Sirota, T.V. Novikova
Anesteziologiya i reanimatologiya.2022; (6): 115. CrossRef - Tough Pill to Swallow: Postextubation Dysphagia and Nutrition Impact in the Intensive Care Unit
Stephanie Dobak, Daniel Kelly
Nutrition in Clinical Practice.2021; 36(1): 80. CrossRef - European white paper: oropharyngeal dysphagia in head and neck cancer
Laura W. J. Baijens, Margaret Walshe, Leena-Maija Aaltonen, Christoph Arens, Reinie Cordier, Patrick Cras, Lise Crevier-Buchman, Chris Curtis, Wojciech Golusinski, Roganie Govender, Jesper Grau Eriksen, Kevin Hansen, Kate Heathcote, Markus M. Hess, Sefik
European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology.2021; 278(2): 577. CrossRef - Dysphagia management in Parkinson's disease: Comparison of the effect of thickening agents on taste, aroma, and texture
Florence Baert, Geertrui Vlaemynck, Anne‐Sophie Beeckman, Stephanie Van Weyenberg, Christophe Matthys
Journal of Food Science.2021; 86(3): 1039. CrossRef - Texture-Modified Diets, Nutritional Status and Mealtime Satisfaction: A Systematic Review
Xiaojing Sharon Wu, Anna Miles, Andrea J. Braakhuis
Healthcare.2021; 9(6): 624. CrossRef - Assessment of tomato‐based thick fluid diet for patients with dysphagia using a simple and cheap test
Helayne Aparecida Maieves, Gerson Lopes Teixeira
Journal of Texture Studies.2021; 52(5-6): 647. CrossRef - Adherence to Dysphagia Treatment Recommendations: A Conceptual Model
Brittany N. Krekeler, Kailey Vitale, Joanne Yee, Ryan Powell, Nicole Rogus-Pulia
Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research.2020; 63(6): 1641. CrossRef - The Geriatric Swallow: Through Thick and Thin
Amanda Fazakerly, Nogah Nativ
Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups.2020; 5(4): 1039. CrossRef - A Free Water Protocol in Inpatient Rehabilitation: Feasibility and Care Outcomes
Stephanie Scibilia, A.M. Barrett, Christina Piscopo, Uri Adler, Ickpyo Hong, Kimberly Hreha
Journal of Korean Society of Occupational Therapy.2020; 28(2): 157. CrossRef - Is IDDSI an Evidence-Based Framework? A Relevant Question for the Frail Older Population
Claudia Côté, Amélie Giroux, Annie Villeneuve-Rhéaume, Cynthia Gagnon, Isabelle Germain
Geriatrics.2020; 5(4): 82. CrossRef - The photographic atlas of Spanish food consistency: a new tool for the treatment of dysphagia
María de las Mercedes Ruiz Brunner, María Elisabeth Cieri, María Pilar Rodríguez Marco, Eduardo Cuestas
Revista Española de Enfermedades Digestivas.2019;[Epub] CrossRef - Patient Adherence to Dysphagia Recommendations: A Systematic Review
Brittany N. Krekeler, Courtney K. Broadfoot, Stephen Johnson, Nadine P. Connor, Nicole Rogus-Pulia
Dysphagia.2018; 33(2): 173. CrossRef - Effect of a Minimal-Massive Intervention in Hospitalized Older Patients with Oropharyngeal Dysphagia: A Proof of Concept Study
A. MartÃn, O. Ortega, M. Roca, M. Arús, Pere Clavé Civit
The Journal of nutrition, health and aging.2018; 22(6): 739. CrossRef - Use of modified diets to prevent aspiration in oropharyngeal dysphagia: is current practice justified?
Shaun T. O’Keeffe
BMC Geriatrics.2018;[Epub] CrossRef - Consistency stability of water thickened with maltodextrin, xanthan gum and potassium chloride
Dauana Cássia Alves, Nattália Araujo Alves, Roberto Oliveira Dantas
Journal of Texture Studies.2017; 48(6): 530. CrossRef - Difficulties in thickened water ingestion in healthy subjects
Dauana Cássia Alves, Roberto Oliveira Dantas
Clinical Nutrition ESPEN.2017; 22: 107. CrossRef - Balancing Eating With Breathing: Community-Dwelling Older Adults’ Experiences of Dysphagia and Texture-Modified Diets
Sandhya Seshadri, Craig R. Sellers, Margaret H. Kearney
The Gerontologist.2017; : gnw203. CrossRef - Diagnosis and Management of Oropharyngeal Dysphagia Among Older Persons, State of the Art
Omar Ortega, Alberto Martín, Pere Clavé
Journal of the American Medical Directors Association.2017; 18(7): 576. CrossRef - A randomised trial of the effect of different fluid consistencies used in the management of dysphagia on quality of life: a time trade-off study: Table 1.
Daniel J. H. Lim, Siofra Maire Mulkerrin, Eamon C. Mulkerrin, Shaun T. O'Keeffe
Age and Ageing.2016; 45(2): 309. CrossRef - Update on management options for dysphagia after acute stroke
Jessica Beavan
British Journal of Neuroscience Nursing.2015; 11(Sup2): 10. CrossRef
