Double-Peak Response in Orthodromic Sensory Nerve Conduction of the Median Nerve

Article information

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

During conventional orthodromic sensory nerve conduction studies (NCS) on the median nerve using surface electrodes, a sensory response characterized by two peaks is occasionally seen during incremental stimulation from minimal to slight strength. With stronger stimulation, the second peak disappeared, and a typical compound sensory action potential (CSAP) with a higher amplitude was recorded.1 According to Stalberg, this second peak originated from the skin receptors or intradermal nerve endings under the anode stimulation.1

A characteristic change in the aging peripheral nerve is that fiber-type grouping is more pronounced distally than proximally.2 The etiology of the fiber-type grouping was presumed secondary to degeneration and regeneration of the peripheral nervous system with secondary reorganization of the muscle fibers belonging to individual motor units.2 The density of large myelinated fibers in the distal portions of the sural nerve reaches a maximum fiber density of 6,480 fibers/mm² by the third decade of life. The large fiber density subsequently and progressively declines to 54% (3480 fibers/mm²) from the second decade to 90 years of age.3 Another change in the peripheral nerve with the aging process is shortening of the internodal length, which can result from demyelination and remyelination. These changes are more pronounced distally in the peripheral nerve.4

With conventional NCS, far distal segments of sensory nerve fibers are not evaluated. The distal segments would reveal the nerve degeneration changes that occur with the aging process. In the present study, we decided to use the orthodromic double-peak response to detect changes in the far distal segments of peripheral nerves that occur with aging in normal subjects. The objective of this study was to understand the pathophysiologic changes that occur with aging and that progress from the far distal segment of the peripheral nerve, and to use the double-peak response to detect peripheral neuropathy that starts at the distal nerve in a centripetal manner.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Methods

Orthodromic NCS was performed with Medtronic Keypoint EMG equipment (Skovlunde, Denmark) in all subjects. The sweep speed was 1 ms/div, sensitivity was 10 µv/div, and the filter setting was 20 Hz-2 kHz. Orthodromic stimulation was performed through a pair of ring electrodes that were 2, 3, or 4 cm apart, with the cathode proximally placed on the third digit for the median nerve. The bipolar recording of the sensory nerve action potential was performed with a surface bar electrode (Medtronic 9013L0221, 23 mm, Denmark, Medtronic) that was placed over the median nerve at the wrist (Fig. 1). A variety of stimulus durations were examined, including 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, and 0.5 ms, and at each stimulus duration, the stimulus intensity was progressively delivered through an increment of 0.2 mA until the double peak appeared. Intensity data of the initial appearance, the maximum, and the disappearance of the double-peak response were obtained. The latency and amplitude of the double peak was detected when the second peak amplitude was maximal, and the first and second double-peak latency and amplitude were obtained (Fig. 2). At each stimulus duration, the interstimulus distance was changed from 2, 3, and 4 cm apart to obtain the interpeak interval. Skin temperatures were constantly maintained at or above 31℃ in the upper limbs.

Fig. 1

Orthodromic stimulation of median sensory nerve on third finger tip.

Fig. 2

Double-peak sensory nerve action potential at slightly increasing stimulation intensity at interstimuli interval of 4 cm and stimulation duration of 0.1 ms. We measured the amplitude as the maximum peak-to-peak amplitude. For example, we detected the second peak amplitude of trace 2 (from 4 to 5). When supramaximal stimulation intensity reached the compound sensory action potential (CSAP) we obtained, we measured the amplitude of CSAP as maximum peak to-peak amplitude (from 2 to 3).

RESULTS

The relationship between aging and the double-peak response

The double-peak response was evoked in all subjects with an interstimulus interval of 4 cm. However, in one 69-year-old subject, double-peak responses were not evoked with the 2 cm or 3 cm interstimulus intervals, and in one 54-year-old subject, it was not evoked with the 2 cm interstimulus interval. With increasing interstimulus intervals from 2 cm to 4 cm, second peak latencies were delayed with increasing age except for the 0.5 ms stimulation duration (Table 1, 3, 5). Second peak amplitudes decreased with increasing age, regardless of the stimulation duration (Table 2, 4, 6). With the same interstimulus interval and stimulation duration, the stimulation intensity increased with aging to evoke maximal amplitude (Fig. 3; r=0.547, p<0.01).

Table 1

Second Peak Latency with Interstimulus Distance 2 cm in Different Stimulation Duration at Each Age Group

Table 3

Second Peak Latency with Interstimulus Distance 3 cm in Different Stimulation Duration at Each Age Group

Table 5

Second Peak Latency with Interstimulus Distance 4 cm in Different Stimulation Duration at Each Age Group

Table 2

Second Peak Amplitude with Interstimulus Distance 2 cm in Different Stimulation Duration at Each Age Group

Table 4

Second Peak Amplitude with Interstimulus Distance 3 cm in Different Stimulation Duration at Each Age Group

Table 6

Second Peak Amplitude with Interstimulus Distance 4 cm in Different Stimulation Duration at Each Age Group

Fig. 3

There was a significant positive relationship between age (year) and stimulation intensity (mA) (r=0.547, p<0.01) by Pearson's correlation test.

The relationship between the anode and the cathode

With the 0.1 ms stimulation duration, the interpeak distance increased from 0.83, 0.97, and 1.15 ms with increasing interstimulus distances of 2, 3, and 4 cm, respectively. With the 0.2, 0.3, and 0.5 ms interstimulus duration, the interpeak distance increased with interstimulus distance (Table 7).

Table 7

Inter-peak Intervals Change with Interstimulus Distance Among Different Duration of Stimulation

DISCUSSION

During conventional orthodromic sensory NCS on the median nerve using surface electrodes, a sensory response characterized by two peaks was occasionally seen during the increase of stimulation from minimal to slight strength. With stronger stimulation, the second peak disappeared, and a typical sensory nerve action potential (SNAP) with a higher amplitude was recorded.1 Buchthal and Rosenfalck,5 using unipolar nerve recordings from the median nerve, obtained a response that consisted of two peaks. The authors believed that the particular sensory response that was evoked with submaximal stimulus was the expression of the fast and slow fibers.5 However, Stalberg1 measured a double-peak response at the digit-wrist and wrist-elbow segments. The sensory nerve conduction velocity (SNCV) was measured for the two peaks separately, and the SNCV of the first and second peaks did not differ. He concluded that the first and second peak originated from the same nerve. In his study, orthodromic stimulation was performed through a pair of ring electrodes with the cathode placed proximally on the third digit for the median nerve. With an increasing interstimulus distance, the increment of the interpeak interval of the double-peak response was found, and he concluded that the double peak originated from the two stimuli, or the anode and the cathode.1 He also found a delay in the first peak latency when the double-peak response was obtained with the anode proximal and the cathode in the distal position, and he explained the cause as an anodal delay. This anodal delay may be evoked by anodal stimulation of the skin sensory receptor or intradermal nerve endings, which are slowed by receptorial delay.1

Capsaicin can induce chemical denervation of epidermal nerve fibers.6,7 Simone and co-workers showed that an intradermal injection of capsaicin produced a decreased sensitivity to pain from mechanical stimuli and nearly eliminated heat evoked pain. These symptoms resulted from rapid degeneration of intracutaneous nerve fibers.8 After capsaicin application to the distal middle finger, there was a reduction in the second peak amplitude of the double-peak response, which suggested a reduction in the functions of skin receptors and intradermal nerve endings. In addition, this finding also showed that the second peak originated from the distal anodal stimulation in orthodromic sensory stimulation.9 This second peak amplitude change is compatible with our data showing second peak amplitude decrement with aging. In addition, we can suspect that the subtle degeneration change that occurs with aging starts from the far distal endings of the peripheral nerve, and this can be diagnosed with the orthodromic double-peak response.

Recent studies on the morphology of the distal peripheral nervous system showed that cutaneous myelinated nerve fibers lose their myelination before their entrance into the dermis and connection to Meissner's corpuscle. The classic criteria, which is based on fiber size (small and large), used to distinguish myelinated fiber populations in sensory nerves no longer seems suitable for identifying myelinated terminations in the skin.10 In fact, instead of a significant variation of fiber diameter along nerves between proximal and distal tapering of nerve fibers, a significant proximal-distal reduction of the internodal length along the nerve trunk was observed. These more recent acquisitions provide evidence that the second peak, which is a result of anodal stimulation, has an initial delay that could be due to a progressive shortening and reduced intermodal length of cutaneous myelinated fibers.11

Histochemical studies of limb muscles from elderly individuals (65 years or older) without evidence of neuromuscular disease revealed fiber size variation, hyaline or granular degeneration, loss of striations, clumps of pyknotic nuclei, increased fat and connective tissue, and most significantly, neurogenic fiber-type grouping.2,12 In addition, there were decreased internodal distances and loss of myelin from sensory myelinated fibers innervating the distal portions of the peripheral nerve. A lessening of the internodal length can result from demyelination and remyelination.2-4 Sensory nerve conduction velocities demonstrate a consistent decline that of nearly 1-2 meters/second per decade.13,14 Compared to the 18-25-year-old group, the SNAP's amplitude is one-half and one-third, respectively, for the 40-60- and 70-88-year-old group.5 The NCS findings may be explained to some degree by considering the histologic changes associated with the aging of the peripheral nervous system. The decrement of amplitude of sensory NCS was demonstrated not only with a cross-sectional study, but also with a prospective study of orthodromic stimulation of the median nerve. In this study, an increment of latency and decrement of conduction velocity was also noted.15,16

These changes of the peripheral nervous system with aging are prominent at far distal areas. However, with conventional NCS, these subtle changes cannot be found. With the orthodromic double-peak response, we can evaluate the distal peripheral nerve. In our study, with the same inter-stimulus distance and duration, there was a decrement of amplitude and an increment of latency of the second peak response. In addition, we found a relationship between stimulus intensity and aging. In some old people, we could not obtain the double-peak response. These changes of the double-peak response represent degeneration and loss of nerve ending receptors in the distal peripheral nerve. In some older age groups, we could not induce the double-peak response with inter-stimulus distances of 2 cm or 3 cm, but with the 4 cm interstimulus distance, we could obtain the double-peak response in all subjects. This finding supports the importance of interstimulus distance. With shorter inter-stimulus distances, there might be an anodal block or refractory period of anodal peak.

One limitation of our study was the small number of subjects in each age group. Especially in the older age groups, there were non-responders. Like the H reflex, which is equivalent to ankle jerk, it is accepted as normal when this cannot be elicited in subjects older than 65 years. Therefore, we did not know the exact meaning of no response in the very old age groups. It is possible that these non-responders represent early length-dependent neuropathies. Secondly, double-peak responses were obtained with upper extremity sensory stimulations only, and so the effects of aging on the motor nerve and lower extremity nerves were not investigated in our experiment. Further study is needed on the double-peak responses in age groups over 70 to understand the differences between aging and disease processes in the very old age group.

CONCLUSION

There was an increment of amplitude, latency, and stimulus intensity and a decrement of conduction velocity of the double peak-response with orthodromic median NCS in normal healthy subjects with aging. In some older aged people, double-peak responses were not obtained.

With the assumption that far distal nerve ending degeneration can be explained with the second peak of the double-peak response, we can use the double-peak response as a screening tool for degenerative peripheral neuropathy with aging, and even for metabolic or toxic peripheral neuropathy with reduced time and cost.

Article information Continued